Since 2005, 380 Chinese companies have executed reverse mergers in the US. They did so, in almost all cases, as a first step towards getting listed on a major US exchange, most often the NASDAQ. Yet, as of today, according to a recent article in Dow Jones Investment Banker, only 15% of those Chinese companies successfully â€œuplistedâ€ to NASDAQ. Thatâ€™s a failure rate of 85%.Â
Thatâ€™s a rather stunning indictment of the advisers and bankers who promote, organize and profit from these transactions. The Chinese companies are left, overwhelmingly, far worse off than when they started. Their shares are stuck trading on the OTCBB or Pink Sheets, with no liquidity, Â steep annual listing and compliance fees, often pathetically low valuations, Â and no hope of ever raising additional capital.Â
The advisors, on the other hand, are coining it. At a guess, Chinese companies have paid out to advisors, accountants, lawyers and Investor Relations firms roughly $700 million in fees for these US reverse mergers. As a way to lower Americaâ€™s balance of payments deficit with China, this one is about the most despicable.Â
You would think that anyone selling a high-priced service with an 85% failure rate would have a hard time finding customers. Sadly, that isnâ€™t the case. This is an industry that quite literally thrives on failure. The US firms specializing in reverse mergers are a constant, conspicuous presence as sponsors at corporate finance conferences around China, touting their services to Chinese companies.
I was at one this past week in Shenzhen, with over 1,000 participants, and a session on reverse mergers sponsored by one of the more prominent US brokerage houses that does these deals. The pitch is always the same: â€œwe can get your company listed on NASDAQâ€.Â
I have no doubt these firms know that 85% of the reverse mergers could be classified as expensive failures, because the companies never migrate to NASDAQ.Â Equally, I have no doubt they never disclose this fact to the Chinese companies they are soliciting. I know a few “laoban” (Chinese for “company boss”) Â whoâ€™ve been pitched by the US reverse merger firms. They are told a reverse merger is all but a Â â€œsure thingâ€. Iâ€™ve seen one US reverse merger firmâ€™s Powerpoint presentation for Chinese clients that contained doctored numbers on performance of firms it brought public on OTCBB.Â Â
Accurate disclosure is the single most important component of financial market regulation. Yet, as far as Iâ€™ve been able to determine, the financial firms pushing reverse mergers offer clients little to no disclosure of their own. No other IPO process has such a high rate of failure, with such a high price tag attached.Â
Of course, the Chinese companies are often also culpable. They fail to do adequate due diligence on their own. Chinese bosses are often too fixated on getting a quick IPO, rather than waiting two to three years, at a minimum, to IPO in China. There’s little Chinese-language material available on the dangers of reverse mergers. These kinds of reverse mergers cannot be done on Chinaâ€™s own stock exchanges. Overall knowledge about the US capital markets is limited.Â
These are the points cited by the reverse merger firms to justify what theyâ€™re doing. But, these justifications ring false. Just because someone wants a vacation house in Florida doesnâ€™t make it OK to sell them swampland in the Everglades.Â
The reverse mergers cost China dear. Good Chinese SME are often bled to death. That hurts Chinaâ€™s overall economy. Chinaâ€™s government probably canâ€™t outlaw the process, since itâ€™s subject to US, not Chinese, securities laws. But, Iâ€™d like to see the Chinese Securities Regulatory Commission (ä¸å›½è¯ç›‘ä¼š), Chinaâ€™s version of the SEC, publish empirical data about US reverse mergers, SPACs, OTCBB listings.Â
There is not much that can be done for the 325 Chinese companies that have already completed a US reverse merger and failed to get uplisted to NASDAQ. They will continue to waste millions of dollars a year in fees just to remain listed on the OTCBB or Pink Sheets, with no realistic prospect of ever moving to the NASDAQ market.
For these companies, the US reverse merger is the capital marketsâ€™ version of å‡Œè¿Ÿ, or â€œdeath by a thousand slicesâ€.