Market capitalization plays a very important part in the success and stability of a Chinese SMEâ€™s shares after IPO. In general, the higher the market capitalization, the less volatility, the more liquidity. All are important if the shares are to perform well for investors after IPO.
There is no simple rule for all companies. But, broadly speaking, especially for a successful IPO in the US or Hong Kong, market capitalization at IPO should be at least $250 million. That will require profits, in the previous year, of around $15mn or more, based on the sort of multiples that usually prevail at IPO.
Companies with smaller market capitalizations at IPO often have a number of problems. Many of the larger institutional investors (like banks, insurance companies, asset management companies) are prohibited to buy shares in companies with smaller market capitalizations. This means there are fewer buyers for the shares, and in any market, whether itâ€™s stock market or the market for apples, the more potential buyers you have, the higher the price will likely climb.
Another problem: many stock markets have minimum market capitalizations in order to stay listed on the exchange. So, for example, if a company IPOs on AMEX market in the US with $5mn in last yearâ€™s profits, it will probably qualify for AMEXâ€™s minimum market capitalization of $75 million. But, if the shares begin to fall after IPO, the market capitalization will go below the minimum and AMEX will â€œde-listâ€ the company, and shares will stop trading, or end up on the OTCBB or Pink Sheets. Once this happens, it can be very hard for a companyâ€™s share price to ever recover.
In general, the stock markets that accept companies with lower profits and lower market capitalizations, are either stock markets that specialize in small-cap companies (like Hong Kongâ€™s GEM market, or the new second market in Shenzhen), or stock markets with lower liquidity, like OTCBB or London AIM.
Occasionally, there are companies that IPO with relatively low market capitalization of around RMB300,000,000 and then after IPO grow fast enough to qualify to move to a larger stock market, like NASDAQ or NYSE. But, this doesnâ€™t happen often. Most low market capitalization companies stay low market capitalization companies forever.
Another consideration in choosing where to IPO is â€œlock upâ€ rules. These are the regulations that determine how long company â€œinsidersâ€, including the SME ownerand his family, must wait before they can sell their shares after IPO. Often, the lock up can be one year or more.
This can lead to a particularly damaging situation. At the IPO, many investment advisors sell their shares on the first day, because they are often not controlled by a lock up and arenâ€™t concerned with the long-term, post-IPO success of the SME client.Â They head for the exit at the first opportunity.
These sales send a bad signal to other investors: â€œif the companyâ€™s own investment advisors donâ€™t want to own the shares, why should we?â€ The closer it gets to this time when the lock up ends, the further the share price falls. This is because other investors anticipate the insiders will sell their shares as soon as it becomes possible to do so.
There are examples of SME bosses who on day of IPO owned shares in their company worth on paper over $50 million, at the IPO price. But, by the time the lock up ends, a year later, those same shares are worth less than $5mn. If itâ€™s a company with a lot market capitalization, there is probably very little liquidity. So, even when the SME bosshas the chance to sell, there are no buyers except for small quantities.
The smaller the market capitalization at IPO, the more risky the lock-in is for the SME boss. Itâ€™s one more reason why itâ€™s so important to IPO at the right time. The higher an SMEâ€™s profits, the higher the price it gets for its shares at IPO. The more money it raises from the IPO, the easier it is to increase profits after IPO and keep the share price above the IPO level.Â Â This way, even when the lock up ends, the SME boss can personally benefit when he sells his shares.
Of all the reasons to IPO, this one is often overlooked: the SME boss should earn enough from the sale of his shares to diversify his wealth. Usually, an SME boss has all his wealth tied up in his company. Thatâ€™s not healthy for either the boss or his shareholders. Done right, the SME boss can sell a moderate portion of his shares after lock in, without impacting the share price, and so often for the first time, put a Â decent chunk of change in his own bank account.
We give this aspect lot of thought in planning the right time and place for an SMEâ€™s IPO. We want our clients’ owners and managers to do well, and have some liquid wealth. Too often up to now, the entrepreneurs who build successful Chinese SMEs do not benefit financially to anything like the extent of the cabal of advisors who push them towards IPO.Â